Comparison
| Roof type | Typical lifespan | Weight per SQ | Relative material cost | Hail | Look |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Asphalt shingles | 15 to 30+ years | 200 to 450 lb | $ | Impact-rated options | Traditional |
| Through-fastened metal | 40+ years | About 50 to 100 lb | $ to $$ | Can dent; heavier gauges resist better | Ribbed, rural to modern |
| Standing seam metal | 50+ years | About 100 to 150 lb | $$$ | Can dent; heavier gauges resist better | Clean, modern |
| Stone-coated steel | 40 to 50+ years | About 125 to 150 lb | $$ to $$$ | Many products impact-rated | Tile, shake, shingle or slate |
| Concrete tile | 50+ years | 900 to 1,200 lb | $$ to $$$ | Can crack | Mediterranean, Southwest |
| Clay tile | 75 to 100+ years | 700 to 1,200 lb | $$$$ | Can crack | Spanish, Mission |
| Synthetic slate | 40 to 50 years | 200 to 400 lb | $$$ | Often impact-rated | Slate |
| Natural slate | 100+ years | 600 to 1,000 lb | $$$$ | Dense stone; some systems Class 4 impact-rated | Classic, timeless |
SQ = one roofing square, 100 sq ft. Typical ranges. Costs are relative and vary by product, market and job. Installation cost is separate.
Questions to ask
How long will you own the building?
If you'll stay 20+ years, a longer-lasting roof may cost less over time.
What's the weather like?
In hail country, look at impact-rated products. In hot climates, light colors and reflective finishes help. Along the coast, look at aluminum and premium paint systems.
Can the structure carry it?
Tile and natural slate weigh more than shingles or metal. Re-roofing a shingle house with tile or slate usually needs an engineer to check the framing; lighter pre-assembled natural slate systems are also available.
What's the roof pitch?
Some products need a steeper roof. See Minimum roof pitch by product.
What fits the house and the neighborhood?
Architecture, HOA rules and nearby homes all matter.
What's the budget?
Include materials, labor, tear-off and any structural work, not just the price per square.
Quick picks
- Lowest up-front cost: asphalt shingles or through-fastened metal
- Longest life: clay tile, natural slate, standing seam
- Light weight with a tile look: stone-coated steel or lightweight concrete tile
- Hail-prone areas: impact-rated shingles, stone-coated steel or heavier-gauge metal
- Low-slope roofs: membranes or standing seam
- A traditional look with metal performance: stone-coated steel, which gives the look of shake, shingle, tile or slate on a light steel panel
