What the ratings mean
Roofing products are tested by dropping steel balls of increasing size onto them. The results are given as impact classes from 1 to 4:
| Class | Steel ball size used in the test |
|---|---|
| Class 1 | 1¼″ |
| Class 2 | 1½″ |
| Class 3 | 1¾″ |
| Class 4 | 2″ |
Class 4 is the highest rating. It means the product did not crack or split when hit with a 2″ steel ball. It doesn't mean the roof is hail-proof, and it may still dent or mark.
Cracking vs denting
The test checks whether the roofing cracks or splits so it no longer keeps water out. A metal roof may dent and still pass. Many insurance policies treat functional damage (leaks, cracks) differently from cosmetic damage (dents). Read your policy, and ask your insurer how they handle cosmetic damage on metal roofs.
How roof types compare
| Roof type | How it handles hail |
|---|---|
| Standard asphalt shingles | Bruising and granule loss; can crack in large hail |
| Impact-resistant shingles | Many are Class 4; reinforced or rubberized mats resist cracking |
| Through-fastened metal | Usually doesn't crack or leak; can dent, especially thinner gauges |
| Standing seam metal | Usually doesn't crack or leak; flat areas can show dents |
| Stone-coated steel | Many products are Class 4; stone layer hides small dents |
| Concrete and clay tile | Can crack in large hail |
| Natural slate | Dense natural stone; some slate systems carry a Class 4 rating |
| Synthetic slate | Many products are impact-rated |
Insurance
In some areas, insurers offer premium discounts for Class 4 roofs. Discounts, rules and paperwork vary, so ask your insurer before choosing. You may need documents showing the product's rating; these are in your account.
Tips for hail-prone areas
- Choose a Class 4 product if your budget allows.
- With metal, a heavier gauge and a ribbed or textured profile resists visible dents better than thin, flat panels.
- Stone-coated steel and textured finishes hide small marks.
- Keep the product documents and installation records for insurance claims.
